Daniel Barkowitz | December 04, 2005
"Part 1 (long delayed) - Parent Contribution from Income"
OK. OK.
The best laid plans...
Since my last post (which was an awfully long time ago) I have been to Charlotte, NC (Thanksgiving), Danvers, MA (Conference), and Atlanta, GA (Conference), but I haven't updated my blog.
Shame on me...
As promised, here is the next part of the EFC Calculation (Parent Contribution from Income):
The contribution from parent income is broken into three different pieces:
- Determining the parents' total income,
- Figuring out allowances against the income, and
- Subtracting the allowances from the total income to determine the available income.
I'll tackle these one step at a time.
For the starting income figure, we take the parents' adjusted gross income figure as reported on the bottom on the first page of the tax return (for simplicity, I will assume that we are talking about a family with two parents; at the end of this process I will do another post explaining the differences for divorced / separated families).
To that we add non-taxable income (which can include a wide variety of income sources -- some are child support received, tax-deferred contributions to retirement programs, tax-exempt interest, etc). [For a more complete list, you may want to look at Worksheets A and B from the FAFSA application for the appropriate sources].
Next we remove from parent income any items listed on Worksheet C of the FAFSA (child support paid, education tax credits, etc).
We add the AGI plus the non-taxable income and subtract the income exclusions to come up with the total income.
Now on to allowances against income. There are five main areas:
- US Income Tax Paid -- we use the actual income tax paid by your parents as reported on the FAFSA and Profile, and as documented by the copy of your tax return,
- State Taxes Paid -- for this calculation, we use a table (two different ones in fact, one for FM and one for CA) to determine how much of your Total Income should be protected to cover state and local taxes,
- FICA or Social Security Taxes -- again, for this line we allow a deduction based on a formula against wages earned from any employment to cover taxes paid to the Social Security system,
- Employment allowance -- for families where both parents are working (or, in a single parent household, where the parent is working) a deduction to allow for the cost of having no one at home (based on a formula and capped at a very low value), and
- Income Protection Allowance (IPA) -- this is meant to be an offset to protect families with particularly low income to protect the entirety of their income before any contribution is expected (even in part) from them.
There are also three additional allowances that are used only under the CA methodology:
- Medical / Dental Expense Allowance -- any amount spent on medical and dental expenses greater than 3.5% of total income is allowed as a deduction under the CA methodology.
- Annual Educational Savings Allowance -- an allowance for savings for other children in the family who are pre-college age (1.52% of total income per pre-college age child). By allowing for this amount, the formula is encouraging families to save some money for college out of current income for younger siblings, and
- Private Elementary and Secondary School Tuition allowance -- an allowance to reflect ongoing costs for private school tuition for younger siblings; no allowance is allowed for the current student applying to college, but a maximum of $7900 per child.
Some other considerations as regards the CA treatment of income:
- For negative income, we do examine whether the loss was truly a cash loss or a paper loss. If the loss is not a true loss (in other words, a loss on the tax return, but not a cash outlay for the family), the loss is added back to the income.
- Depreciation (whether on a business return or a rental return) is also considered to be a paper loss and therefore is added back to income.
- For families living in a metro area with a high cost of living, we use an optional regionally based cost of living allowance in the CA formula to allow for an increased IPA.
As a reminder then, the difference between total income and total allowances is set aside as Available Income (we will come back to this number later).
So, lots of information, and I'm sure this will generate many questions, so ask away!
|
The author has filed this entry in the "Financial Aid" section; check it out for further reading on this topic. |
Responses To This Entry:
(Please note that comments are closed after 30 days to reduce spam.)"CA methodology": does this mean California?
Posted by: Parent on December 5, 2005 11:45 AM
how do you calculate that for international students? do you consider how devalued is the country's coin against the dollar?
Posted by: Carla on December 5, 2005 07:57 PM
"how do you calculate that for international students?"
This is something I want to know, too.
Posted by: Momchil Minkov on December 8, 2005 03:58 PM
"how do you calculate that for international students?"
This is something I want to know, too.
Posted by: Momchil Minkov on December 8, 2005 04:00 PM
How can you calculate that for international students?
Posted by: Mercedes on December 11, 2005 12:13 PM
yes, international students...
Posted by: Vaqif on January 16, 2006 09:47 AM
International students, once more ...?
Posted by: Natasha on January 27, 2006 07:26 PM
Does mortgage payment or rent payment for primary home get deducted from income?
Posted by: David on September 22, 2006 01:07 AM
The only way in which mortgage or rent payments are taken into account is through the offset to income in the Income Protection Allowance (IPA). This is, by design, a low figure, and meant (as stated above) to be a protection for the lowest income families, recognizing that for these families, no amount of income can be contributed to college. The citation from the Feds (see http://www.ifap.ed.gov/sfahandbooks/attachments/0607AVGCh3.pdf for more info) reads like this:
This allowance is for the basic living expenses of a family. It varies according to the number in the parents’ household and the number in college in 2006–07, as reported on the FAFSA. In general, a school can assume that 30% of the income protection allowance amount is for food, 22% for housing, 9% for transportation expenses, 16% for clothing and personal care, 11% for medical care, and 12% for other family consumption.
Don't, however, expect colleges to raise this figure if your expenses exceed that 22% figure, however, since this figure is supposed to be for the expenses of the lowest income families.
Posted by: Daniel Barkowitz on September 22, 2006 01:41 PM
I have two questions about parental income. First, I don't think the methodologies take into account the parent's consumer (credit card) debt, which, of course, needs minimum monthly payments, etc., and can be an important financial drain. Say the parent owes $20,000 in credit card debt and then becomes executor of an estate for which he is paid $20,000 as a one-time fee (taxed as income),which is then used to pay down the consumer debt. Likely effect on FinAid for a Junior? Second, what if the $20,000 is in the bank when the forms are due -- isn't this one-time money counted twice, once as "income" then as an "asset?"
Posted by: John on September 24, 2006 10:32 AM
Thanks for the comment, John. And here are your answers:
You are correct that neither methodology takes consumer debt into account (credit cards, car loans, bank loans, etc) as these are viewed as (don't laugh) discretionary (OK, why are you chuckling?). That said, the scenario you describe is exactly the kind of situation in which a financial aid officer would be encouraged to use his/her professional judgment to make a change to the standard formula to account for what you have raised. Of course, we would not want to "double count" an income source as both an income in a tax year as well as an asset, and we make all kinds of adjustments where these kinds of situations arise.
Posted by: Daniel Barkowitz on September 25, 2006 03:07 PM
